Article
Which shirt with a suit: blue, grey, black
A shirt is not matched to the suit: it is set apart from it. That is why white works almost always — and why on a brown suit it works badly.
This article is about day suits, the ones worn for work or for a ceremony. Black tie and morning dress have rules of their own, and they are real rules: there the shirt is a single one.
The one rule: contrast, not matching
Choosing a shirt the same colour as the suit means trying to make two things agree that are not meant to agree. The shirt has one job: to separate your face from the cloth of the suit, and to do it so that you can see where one ends and the other begins.
That is why white works almost always: it is the only colour that competes with nothing. Light blue is the second white — it sets apart a little less, it is less severe, and on a suit worn to work every day it is often the better choice.
Everything else is not a rule but a choice, and a choice can be got wrong. The four lines below say where.
| Suit | The shirt that always works | The second one | Leave it alone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blue | White | Light blue | Blue in the same tone |
| Grey | White | Light blue, pale pink | Grey in the same tone |
| Black | White | Ivory | Stripes, and black on black |
| Brown, beige | Cream | Dusty blue | Optical white |
Blue suit: the one that forgives most
Blue is the easiest suit there is, because blue is a cool, middling colour: it sits well with the cool ones and does not quarrel with the warm ones. White for when it counts, light blue the rest of the time, and both work with any tie.
Pale pink over a blue suit works better than almost everyone believes, and you see it on Italians more than elsewhere: it warms a pairing that would otherwise be all cool. Fine white and light blue stripes are the other road, and they work under a jacket because under a jacket little of them shows.
Leave alone: a blue shirt in the same tone as the suit, which from a distance looks like a uniform, and black, which on a daytime blue has no reason to be there.
Grey suit: the one that accepts the most colours
Grey is neutral by definition, so it is the suit that accepts the widest range. White and light blue as always; but also pale pink, and pale lilac, which on a blue would be out of place and here belong.
Light grey with a white shirt is the daytime ceremony pairing: a morning wedding, a christening, a graduation. It is lighter than blue and less severe than black, and that is the reason it exists.
Leave alone: the grey shirt. Grey on grey, unless the two tones are very far apart, reads as a crumpled suit rather than as a choice.
Black suit: the uncomfortable truth
A black suit by day is difficult, and it is worth saying so: it was born as evening dress, and by day it suits few people and few occasions. In most cases a very dark blue or a charcoal grey does the same job better.
If the black suit is there, the shirt is white. This is not laziness: black is the highest-contrast colour you can put on, and any other colour beside it becomes the thing people look at. Ivory is the only variant that holds, and it serves to take the hardness away when black is close to the face.
Leave alone: stripes, which on a black suit become noise, and the black shirt, which is either a deliberate, considered choice or it is nothing. And for a funeral: a white shirt, a dark tie or no tie — but then a collar that stands up on its own, or an open neck looks careless rather than sober.
Brown or beige suit: here white makes it worse
This is the case where the rule reverses, and it is the piece of information missing from almost every page that answers this question. Brown, tobacco and beige are warm colours; optical white is cool, and next to a warm one a cool one does not set apart: it jars.
The right shirt is an off white — cream, ivory, bone — which has inside it the same yellow the suit has. The second colour is dusty blue, which is cool but muted, and with browns it does what light blue does with blues.
And there is a reason you see this rarely: cream white is hard to find in ready-made shirts, because factories make the optical white that goes with everything else. It is one of the few cases where made to measure solves a problem that otherwise does not get solved.
The collar, the cuff and the centimetre that shows
Under a jacket the collar has to hold: if the points rise or escape outwards over the lapel, the most correct colour pairing in the world is not even seen. It is a question of structure, not of colour — the guide on collars goes into it.
And then there is the cuff, the detail that tells a suit that fits from one that merely sits on you: from the jacket sleeve, between one and one and a half centimetres of shirt should show. No more, no less.
That centimetre depends on two measurements — the length of the shirt sleeve and the height of the cuff — and in a ready-made shirt both are decided by the size. It is the most concrete, and least romantic, reason why a made-to-measure shirt shows on a man even to someone who does not know he is looking at it.
A collar that sits under the lapel and a cuff showing a centimetre: those are two measurements, and in the configurator you choose them yourself.
Design your shirt
